The future of our pubs

CHEERS? Half of "tied pubs" in the UK earn less then £15,000 a year. So what can be done to help them survive?
CHEERS? Half of “tied pubs” in the UK earn less then £15,000 a year. So what can be done to help them survive?

OLDHAM Council has agreed to carry out a review of pubs across the Borough to address growing concerns from people about the rapid pace of local closures.

Pubs are important to the fabric of our town, and also our nation.

Many overseas visitors look forward to sampling a ‘good British pub’, such is their symbolic place in our cultural history – and as part of our national identity.

But rose-tinted views of the perfect British pub fall some way off the mark when you compare them with the reality of our changing towns in 2013.

There are many varied and complex reasons why pubs are struggling but the sheer number of closures should raise the alarm with anyone who recognises that pubs are not simply a place to buy a pint, but also a vital community asset.

In many villages the shops have closed and post offices are gone, but the humble pub remains – for now.

The Campaign for Real Ale (CAMRA) is estimating that around 1,000 more pubs will close in the next 12 months.

In Oldham itself we have seen 50 licences for bars and clubs surrendered from January 2008 to date – and there will be some premises that still have licences in force that have also closed but are not yet counted.

So, if pubs are such a vital part of our fabric, why are they under so much threat?

Nationally consumer trends are leaning towards more and more people drinking socially at home.

It’s cheaper and couples can also have a drink together without worrying about childcare.

Increasingly the pubs which do well are those that are serving good quality food but – for an average couple with two children – that is a rare treat, given the cost.

Here in Oldham and many other places the cultural mix has also changed.

In many places the community doesn’t drink alcohol and therefore simply wouldn’t use a pub as a matter of course.

And I suppose if we class pubs as community assets the community also has to want them and use them –  and if they don’t then that’s fine too.

The Government has just announced proposals for a new code of conduct on the issue of abuse of the ‘beer tie’: whereby landlords are forced into only buying supplies from the pub companies that own the venues, and often at high prices.

It will apply to those companies owning more than 500 pubs – targeting the area where it says 90 per cent of complaints are received.

But taxation is also a large part of the issue here – and successive governments have failed to address the impact of this on what are very low margin sales.

The Government did freeze the beer duty increase in this year’s Budget, saving 1p off the price of a pint, but that measure from Mr Osbourne, I’m afraid, completely missed the scale of the challenge.

Based on my own modest intake of a couple of pints a week it would take me almost five years before I earned back my first free pint – Cheers, George!

Breweries themselves have to take a long hard look in the mirror too.

Not all of them are the same, but it’s clear that some in the industry are pricing themselves out of the market. High rents and expensive ‘ties’ on stock mean it is very difficult for a landlord to make any kind of a reasonable wage to live on.

The pressure to ‘realise a return’ on assets sees many landlords paying rents as high as £77,000 a year – the rate for one Oldham pub currently being advertised (The Grapes, Lees).

That is also on top of your Business Rates, staffing and running costs – plus the small matter of stock.

The best way to protect your local pub as a resident for now is, quite simply, to use it.

But I am looking forward to seeing what the cross-party Overview and Scrutiny Committee examining this issue in Oldham comes up with.

Let’s hope they can offer some real practical solutions that can help our landlords and communities alike.

Thanks for listening,


3 thoughts on “The future of our pubs

  1. Angela Fordham

    We had the Golden Fleece and the brewery made it harder and harder to stay. Increasing rents, expensive tie ins and offering no help until we had put everything we had saved and more in. The best decision we made was to get out. Brewery’s are just greedy and will never learn. How most pub’s survive I haven’t got a clue because as you stated its not just the rent and tie in, the gas, electric, business rates, staffing and the list goes on. It’s about time the tenants got a break and the brewery’s were brought down a peg or two. We ended up owing over 15000.00 to Punch Taverns. This was paid and still they chase you. Taking on a pub, was the worse decision we ever made. Now we get paid to work and have time off instead of us paying to work and working and worrying 24/7.

  2. shaun mcgrath

    At last, a well-reasoned discussion of the myriad problems facing the ailing pub industry, that doesn’t cite the smoking ban, as one of the contributing factors.

  3. I have noticed this worrying trend. I only moved to Oldham (Greenfield) in August 2010, and the lovely country pub ‘The Clarence’ has already changed hands several times since then. The family used to go fairly often, but over the last year or so we hardly go at all, as the quality of the food has been increasingly getting worse – but then this is to be expected if pubs change hands so often that owners are unable to stay long enough to really put effort in and make their own mark. It really is a shame.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s